Housed within the historic Maccabees hall, Caseville Museum strives to offer visitors an opportunity to trace the city's history through its immersive displays. Established in 2008, the museum is managed by the Historical Society of Caseville, which aims to promote an understanding of the area's culture and traditions.

In 1868 the Reverend Manasseh Hickey and twelve settlers organized a Methodist Episcopal church in Caseville. Services were held in a schoolhouse until the present church was built. Upon its dedication on November 15, 1874, the Gothic-inspired structure, with its 70-foot-high steeple, became a focal point for the community.